,

SAT defended from ‘misguided’ attacks as test increasingly becomes optional for students

Standardized testing for college admissions has come under intense scrutiny, especially during the COVID pandemic. But some administrators and testing experts are arguing that the backlash against tests like the SAT and ACT is unfair and based on little evidence, according to The New York Times.

“[A] growing number of experts and university administrators wonder whether the switch has been a mistake,” New York Times reporter David Leonhardt wrote in a feature on the trend away from testing requirements at U.S. colleges. 

“Research has increasingly shown that standardized test scores contain real information, helping to predict college grades, chances of graduation and post-college success,” Leonhardt wrote in a feature from Sunday. “Test scores are more reliable than high school grades, partly because of grade inflation in recent years.”

Some administrators at America’s top universities agree that tests like the SAT and ACT are valuable predictors of academic success. “Standardized test scores are a much better predictor of academic success than high school grades,” president of Brown University Christina Paxson wrote in a letter published in June. 

BILL BENNETT REACTS TO NEW DATA SHOWING THE US IS BEHIND IN MATH: ‘CONSENSUS HAS BROKEN DOWN’

Dean of admissions at MIT Stuart Schmill told the Times that grades did not tell the entire story of a student. “Just getting straight A’s is not enough information for us to know whether the students are going to succeed or not,” Schmill said. 

Schmill has also argued that MIT, one of the few elite institutions in the U.S. that maintained its testing requirement, actually increased diversity on campus. “Once we brought the test requirement back, we admitted the most diverse class that we ever had in our history,” Schmill told The Times. “Having test scores was helpful.”

“Test scores have vastly more predictive power than is commonly understood in the popular debate,” Brown University economics professor John Friedman said. Friedman was one of the authors of a study on the importance of testing for highly selective colleges in the U.S. 

Liberals have led the outcry against standardized testing, claiming that the tests discriminate against Black and Hispanic students, who tend to score lower than White and Asian students. 

ACT TEST SCORES HIT NEW 30-YEAR LOW

Leonhardt, however, objected to the argument that “racial and economic gaps in SAT and ACT scores” prove that the “tests are biased.” 

“After all, most measures of life in America — on income, life expectancy, homeownership and more — show gaps,” he wrote for the New York Times. “No wonder: Our society suffers from huge inequities. The problem isn’t generally with the statistics, however. The relatively high Black poverty rate is not a sign that the statistic is biased. Nor would scrapping the statistic alleviate poverty.”

“When you don’t have test scores, the students who suffer most are those with high grades at relatively unknown high schools, the kind that rarely send kids to the Ivy League,” Harvard economist David Deming said. “The SAT is their lifeline.”

Other professors advocate for an entirely revolutionary admissions system to higher education. University of California Riverside professor Eddie Comeaux told The Times that “[h]aving a lottery” would force the education system to “radically rethink what it means to gain access and also to learn, rather than accepting the status quo.”

Some school administrators said that the conversation about standardized testing is a highly political one. For progressives, supporting tests like the SAT and ACT can be dangerous. 

“It’s not politically correct,” Georgetown University admissions dean Charles Deacon told Intelligencer in a 2022 interview.

 

PATRIOT WATCHDOG ALERTS
STAY IN THE LOOP

📬 Join our community of patriots & and stay vigilant by keeping an eye on the proceedings.
Get “early alerts” from some of your favorite conservative news sources, exclusive reports, network-only offers, and political content delivered straight to your inbox.

🇺🇸 #PatriotWatch2024 🇺🇸

The 2024 election 🇺🇸 is upon us, and it's crucial that we stay informed and united. Join us and show your support. Help to see that our democracy thrives!

Living Under Democratic Rule

A Survival Guide For Republicans, Conservatives, & Libertarians

Democrats hate the Constitution. They hate individual liberty. They hate freedom. But they didn’t just wake up this morning snarling and twirling their handlebar mustaches, born with an innate desire to be “the bad guys.”

Democrats’ hatred for your liberty has a driving force: the need to control

Living Under Democrat Rule will first take you a little deeper into what makes Democrats such a problem. Then we’ll explain how important it is to your well-being to be smarter than the Democrats.

Patriot Watchdog: Election 2024

Join For Updates & Show Your Support For Election 2024

(politics) Elect Form

— SUPPORT 2024 ELECTION —

Patriot Watchdog: News, Politics, Opinion & More

Stay in the loop! 📬 Join our community and get the latest updates, exclusive content, special offers and political content delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscription Form
Trump Campaign 2024 - Support For The Right @RedAsHell.com
(politics) Get the latest updates news and more politics content.

Patriot Watchdog: News, Politics, Opinion & More

Stay in the loop! 📬 Join our community and get the latest updates, exclusive content, special offers and political content delivered straight to your inbox. 

Exclusively for patriots who support viewpoints that lean towards a conservative or "right-wing" perspective. Members of this network support viewpoints that lean towards a conservative or "right-wing" perspective and believe in the importance of preserving traditional values and principles, and support commentary that reflects these beliefs.

What can you expect? You can expect to see news, commentary and content of a conservative nature, receive periodic newsletter emails (which you can turn on/off as you wish), optionally engage in meaningful discussions/share insights, gain access to exclusive tools/resources and stay informed about the latest developments in the US economy, news, and politics. Access is always 100% free and active participation is optional. 


Calling All Red Blooded Patriots...

Patriot Watchdog: election 2024
Are You IN Or Out?

Attention all red-blooded patriots! 🇺🇸 The 2024 election is upon us, and it's crucial that we stay informed and united. Join RedaShell's Patriot Watchdog to keep a vigilant eye on the proceedings and show your unwavering support. Stand with us, be the voice of the nation, and let's ensure our democracy thrives! #PatriotWatch2024"

JOIN OUR CONSERVATIVE NETWORK

GET CONSERVATIVE COMMENTARY & UPDATES DIRECTLY IN YOUR INBOX

Subscription Form

youir privacy is 100% protected