What Rashida Tlaib reveals about how the left really feels on antisemitism

According to Michigan Democrat Rep. Rashida Tlaib, the term “from the river to the sea,” is a call for “freedom, human rights, and peaceful coexistence.” According to many others, including Hamas, it is a call to destroy Israel even at the cost of Jewish lives. 

Even after being censured by the House of Representatives for her antisemitic remarks and for spreading Hamas propaganda, with 22 Democrats voting to rebuke her, Tlaib doubled down, saying she would not be silenced and that her words were being distorted. 

So how are we to determine where pro-Palestinian sentiment ends and antisemitism begins? 


Over at the progressive New York Magazine, Eric Levitz has an answer. What’s not surprising is that it exonerates Tlaib, what is surprising is that it is an absolute refutation of two decades of progressive orthodoxy about bigotry. 

Here’s what he says: 

“Too often, arguments about antisemitism get bogged down in assertations about a given claim’s motivation, which in most cases is unknowable. So in determining whether a statement should be branded as antisemitic, let’s focus on its explicit meaning, not its alleged motivation.” 

It is utterly astounding. 

This is the 180-degree opposite of everything the left has said about racism, sexism and transphobia as it pounded into our heads that we shouldn’t use terms like “you guys,” “peanut gallery,” or “mother” even if our motivation is purely innocent. 

They reinforce harmful stereotypes, you see. 

The entire basis of critical race theory from Peggy McIntosh’s “Invisible Knapsack” to Ibram X Kendi’s “Antiracist Baby” is that motivation or intent is completely irrelevant when judging if a statement is racist.

Why is this rule different for antisemitism? Why is anything short of “I want you in a gas chamber,” nuanced? 

We have also been told that demographic groups themselves decide what is and isn’t offensive to say about them. If a Black person or a gay person or a Martian tells us something crosses a line, the left says we must respect that. 

But here we have Jews all over the country insisting not only that these slogans are antisemitic and hurtful, but that they are causing legitimate fear of violence. 

Where is the “words are literally violence” crowd as Jewish students are accosted and harassed on college campuses, in one case by the editor of Harvard Law Review. 

The double standard is glaring. 

For every other group, we must walk on ever-shifting eggshells so as not to microagress, but when it comes to Jews, well, they oughta just be less sensitive. 

This is the pernicious and predictable, actual bigotry of a progressive left that can only see things through the lens of oppressor and oppressed. 

In this sad, twisted matrix, the oppressed can never be wrong, no matter how foul their motivations, no matter how many they kill. And the oppressor, unless they are actively fighting the alleged oppression, props up systemic bigotry merely by existing. 

The saddest part of this is that, of course, Levitz is correct. Obviously, motivation and intent should be taken into account with allegations of bigotry. But if we apply this standard, with its high bar to antisemitism, why not to every form of bigotry? 

It is possible to make a distinction between someone marching in general support of Palestinians and someone chanting, “Glory to the martyrs,” which is very much an explicit call to murder more Jews.

That is a distinction that most Americans would be comfortable with, but Tlaib and her band of loony leftists won’t even call out “Glory to the martyrs.”


No, for today’s American progressive, the double standard is the point. The rules of political correctness were never rules at all. They were an academic Rube Goldberg device meant to distract from the left’s one and only true goal, power. 

In pursuit of this power, or as they call it, social justice, anything is fair game, even tearing down missing posters of kidnapped babies being held hostage. 

Americans must, and eventually will, defeat this perverse ideology that places us all into demographic boxes and turns a sly, blind eye to even abject antisemitism.

But until that happens, until our society utterly rejects the double standards of identity politics, a lot of Jews are going to take a lot of abuse, and silence in the face of that abuse is indeed complicity. 



📬 Join our community of patriots & and stay vigilant by keeping an eye on the proceedings.
Get “early alerts” from some of your favorite conservative news sources, exclusive reports, network-only offers, and political content delivered straight to your inbox.

🇺🇸 #PatriotWatch2024 🇺🇸

The 2024 election 🇺🇸 is upon us, and it's crucial that we stay informed and united. Join us and show your support. Help to see that our democracy thrives!

Living Under Democratic Rule

A Survival Guide For Republicans, Conservatives, & Libertarians

Democrats hate the Constitution. They hate individual liberty. They hate freedom. But they didn’t just wake up this morning snarling and twirling their handlebar mustaches, born with an innate desire to be “the bad guys.”

Democrats’ hatred for your liberty has a driving force: the need to control

Living Under Democrat Rule will first take you a little deeper into what makes Democrats such a problem. Then we’ll explain how important it is to your well-being to be smarter than the Democrats.

Patriot Watchdog: Election 2024

Join For Updates & Show Your Support For Election 2024

(politics) Elect Form


Patriot Watchdog: News, Politics, Opinion & More

Stay in the loop! 📬 Join our community and get the latest updates, exclusive content, special offers and political content delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscription Form
(politics) Get the latest updates news and more politics content.

Patriot Watchdog: News, Politics, Opinion & More

Stay in the loop! 📬 Join our community and get the latest updates, exclusive content, special offers and political content delivered straight to your inbox. 

Exclusively for patriots who support viewpoints that lean towards a conservative or "right-wing" perspective. Members of this network support viewpoints that lean towards a conservative or "right-wing" perspective and believe in the importance of preserving traditional values and principles, and support commentary that reflects these beliefs.

What can you expect? You can expect to see news, commentary and content of a conservative nature, receive periodic newsletter emails (which you can turn on/off as you wish), optionally engage in meaningful discussions/share insights, gain access to exclusive tools/resources and stay informed about the latest developments in the US economy, news, and politics. Access is always 100% free and active participation is optional. 

Calling All Red Blooded Patriots...

Patriot Watchdog: election 2024
Are You IN Or Out?

Attention all red-blooded patriots! 🇺🇸 The 2024 election is upon us, and it's crucial that we stay informed and united. Join RedaShell's Patriot Watchdog to keep a vigilant eye on the proceedings and show your unwavering support. Stand with us, be the voice of the nation, and let's ensure our democracy thrives! #PatriotWatch2024"



Subscription Form

youir privacy is 100% protected